Your ultimate guide to employee engagement

What is employee engagement?

A definition of employee engagement is how much an employee is committed to helping their organisation achieve its goals. It’s demonstrated by how employees think, feel, and act, as well as the emotional connection employees, feel towards their Organization, their work, and their team.

Currently, 36% of U.S. employees are engaged in their work and workplace, which matches Gallup’s composite percentage of engaged employees in 2020. Globally, 20% of employees are engaged at work.

Get started with our free employee engagement survey template

Why is employee engagement important?

Research shows that employee engagement initiatives make people more inclined to work harder and solve problems, grow and develop faster, get along with people better, and stay longer at a company. All these factors have a measurable business impact, and contribute to organisational success:

• Increased performance – SHRM research shows that people who are engaged in their work are more likely to help the company achieve its goals
• Higher employee retention – according to the Oxford Handbook of Positive Psychology at Work, an engaged employee is 87% less likely to leave their organisation. This means reduced employee turnover costs for HR professionals having to recruit new staff, train them and wait for them to ramp up to full productivity
• Higher job satisfaction – when your workforce is happy it enriches your workplace culture
• Increased revenue – according to Gallup, highly engaged employees contribute to 21% greater profitability and those teams who score in the top 20% in engagement realize a 41% reduction in absenteeism, and 59% less attrition – better business outcomes all round
• A better customer experience – the same Gallup study found that high workplace engagement contributes to a 10% increase in customer ratings and a 20% increase in sales, which in turn can lead to…
• Higher customer loyalty and customer retention result from highly engaged employees

Why employee engagement alone is not enough

Employee engagement is important, and a good thing, for all the reasons listed above. However, it’s not the full picture. When you think about it, employees can be engaged, and:

• still want to leave your organisation
• still be at risk of burnout
• still not feel like they belong
• still struggle with unwieldy technology experiences and processes

It’s no longer enough to measure engagement alone. As a metric, it doesn’t give your organisation the full picture of the experiences your employees are having at work on a day-to-day basis. An organisation needs that full picture – the employee experience (EX) – to drive better business outcomes at the top and bottom lines.

Priorities shift and business leaders, managers and teams need to keep up with them, and an annual engagement survey is no longer enough. You need to solve the challenges of measuring more than engagement, more often, without adding to already busy people’s workloads. More needs to be measured with less. So…

Employee engagement strategies

Shift mindset from employee engagement initiatives to employee experience (EX)

Just as the rise of the service economy opened the door to employee engagement, the experience economy has seen a shift towards ‘employee experience’ – a more holistic view of the workforce that sees engagement as just one lever to pull.

And it’s important to remember that it’s up to the company to provide the experience. Your company culture and company mission must now support, encourage and empower a great employee experience.

Today’s most successful organizations are looking not just at an annual or bi-annual snapshot of how their employees feel, but are running employee listening programs that gather feedback throughout the employee lifecycle. We call this experience data (or X-data) as it seeks to understand the complete employee experience.

Understand the key performance indicators (KPIs) of employee experience

These are the measurements that a company should track to ensure they are providing a great employee experience:

Engagement (the definitive KPI)

Engagement remains the gold standard employee measurement, strongly linked to organisational outcomes, such as performance, customer satisfaction, retention, strong company culture, and innovation. It measures employees’:

• Likelihood to recommend your organisation
• Willingness to go above and beyond
• Sense of accomplishment at work

Intent to stay

Once part of engagement, this measures how long your employees say they intend to stay at your organisation.

Experience vs. expectations

Employees indicate to what extent their expectations are met at work. Their answers will provide unique perspectives, reflecting employees’ individual expectations. Once you’ve collected the data, you can easily segment results to differentiate the experiences of employees based on whether the organisation is exceeding, meeting, or falling short of expectations.

Inclusion

Inclusion has become a key differentiator between a positive company culture and a negative one. Inclusive organizations are more innovative, productive, and enjoy higher retention. This KPI assesses:

• Belonging
• Authenticity
• Equity

Wellbeing

This important measure is becoming more critical as the lines between work and home increasingly blur, post-pandemic. It’s essential that employers create working environments conducive to well-being, so that employees don’t risk burnout, presenteeism, and/or low productivity.

This KPI measures employees’:

• Energy
• Positivity
• Relationships

Understand the key drivers of employee experience

Drivers are aspects of employee experience that influence the five KPIs. Key drivers of EX include:

Gather employee engagement data using surveys

Consider the lifetime of an employee at your organisation (the employee journey) – there are key milestones along the way, whether it’s their interview, new job onboarding process, performance reviews as well as other surveys that crop up during their career.

Each survey presents an opportunity to gather feedback and understand the key drivers of engagement and how to improve that experience:

• Always-on employee feedback – an on-demand, anonymous avenue where employees can raise issues and provide feedback.
• Ad hoc surveys – just-in-time feedback on specific initiatives eg. organisational changes, job satisfaction
• Employee lifecycle feedback – event-triggered feedback that gets employees’ views at key milestones in their journey with a company. It includes candidate, new hire, onboarding, exit, and training feedback
• Multi-rater assessments – performance and development evaluations that simplify the 360 reviews and feedback from peers, managers, and direct reports
• Census engagement surveys – the annual or bi-annual ‘deep dive’, it covers the widest range of topics and allows you to understand the key drivers of engaged employees and identify areas for improvement

Enlightened employee experience leaders also take into account operational data (O-data) such as employee churn rates, adoption of benefits programs, participation in affinity groups, etc. Combining this with experience data (X-data) allows HR leaders to get an even fuller picture of their people’s experience.

Get the right insights to the right people

It’s essential to map out who gets which insights to action them. The data must go to someone who can do something with it. There’s little that’s more dispiriting for employees than to give feedback, then nothing gets done as a result. Executives will need different insights to managers, and HR leaders will need different insights altogether.

Get started with our free employee engagement survey template

Employee engagement surveys step by step

1. Start with survey design

Designing an effective survey is part of your employee engagement strategy and requires careful thought to return the best possible results and data. To start, keep your survey structure simple and intuitive. Employees will need to understand how to answer the questions and your managers will need to understand how to read the report. Your goal is for as many employees as possible to understand and act on the results of your engagement survey.

Here’s what else you’ll need to think about before you get started:

• Decide whose input you need to include and whose input you don’t need (manage expectations by explaining why you are not consulting them).
• Set clear deadlines and turnaround times right from the start
• Ask participants to let you know upfront if they cannot meet the timeframe, so you can assign someone else
• Establish one person for the final sign-off, and make it clear to everyone in the sign-off process that when they say it’s final, it’s final
• Distinguish ‘nice to have’ questions from ‘must have’ questions
• Avoid designing your employee engagement survey by committee

2. Devise the right questions to ask your employees

Your employee engagement survey should not only help you solve a problem at your organisation, but also point to what you’re doing right in the eyes of engaged employees. To improve employee engagement, you need to be sure that your questions are going to deliver useful insights into their employee experience.

If you’re starting to worry about formulating the right employee engagement survey questions, don’t. Designing your own employee engagement survey means that you don’t have to ask a question in a certain way to fit into a particular model – every question can be designed to be 100% relevant to your organisation, which can help make your survey shorter and easier to digest.

Your questions should cover three key areas:

Employee engagement

These questions go at the front of your survey, and measure: intent to stay, work involvement, discretionary effort, pride in the company, and willingness to recommend the organisation.

Core themes

These ask about the conditions that might cause (or detract from) employee engagement with questions about autonomy and empowerment, career progression, collaboration, communication, leadership, recognition, resources, strategy, management support, and training and development.

Additional themes

Depending on what’s happening in your company or market at the time, you might also want to ask about additional topics. In our employee engagement survey template you’ll find some additional ones you can include. Try to avoid throwing them all in, and only ask them if they’re relevant to prevent your engagement survey from becoming too unwieldy.

3. Identify the key drivers you want to measure

Your next step is to identify the themes you want to measure, and then create employee engagement survey questions that support those themes. As a rule of thumb, aim to ask 30-50 employee experience-related questions. Remember to include a way to record demographics, too.

Tip: In line with the industry standard, we recommend that employee engagement surveys use a 5-point Likert scale for all items:

• Agreement Scale: Strongly Agree to Strongly Disagree
• Rating Scale: Very Good to Very Poor

Examples of great employee engagement survey questions

These effective sample employee engagement survey questions will help you to distinguish the current employee satisfaction level. You’ll notice the questions cover several of the key engagement themes mentioned above.

Q1 How satisfied or dissatisfied are you with your ability to do interesting work in your role?

Q2 How satisfied or dissatisfied are you with your ability to apply your skills in this role?

Q3 How satisfied or dissatisfied are you with your current workload?

Q4 How satisfied or dissatisfied are you with your opportunities for career progression?

Q5 How satisfied or dissatisfied are you with the physical environment at your workplace?

Q6 How satisfied or dissatisfied are you with your relationship with your manager?

Q7 Overall, how satisfied or dissatisfied are you with your current employer?

Examples of poor employee engagement survey questions

The point of employee engagement survey questions is to achieve accurate responses and a high employee feedback response rate. By including questions that are obscure, too difficult to answer, too demanding, or too personal, you risk your survey being abandoned or discredited. Some terrible questions about employee experience we have seen include:

Q1 Does traveling for work affect your relationship with your partner (if you have one)? Far too personal and intrusive!

Q2 Does your manager appear to favour some employees over others? Who? Employees will be too afraid to answer this and unwilling to snitch on colleagues

Q3 What has been your experience of working with the company over the last year? Where to begin with this? Do you want an essay? Far too long and demanding.

Q4 On a scale of 1 to 10 how fairly do you think your manager treats the team? (1 being extremely unfairly, 10 being very fairly) Fairness is a subjective concept, particularly when you are being asked to answer for other people as well here, and impossible to pin on a scale of 1 to 10. There’s no definite answer, therefore a pointless question.

Q5 What KPIs do you think we achieved B2B in the YTD? Just what does this mean? (Translation: what key performance indicators do you think we achieved business to business in the year to date?) Avoid jargon and acronyms in your surveys, although even without the acronyms this is a pretty poor question.

Your employee engagement survey checklist

Every organisation will have its own needs when it comes to assessing employee engagement. To expedite the process, we’ve created a survey template and outlined the steps to take to get your employee engagement survey up and running.

Run your survey

To ensure you collect the greatest amount of responses, properly survey employees by inviting everyone in your company to respond, and keep a close eye on response rates. You might need to keep the survey open for two to three weeks to give people the best opportunity to give their feedback.

Measuring employee engagement

So, what factors lead to engaged employees? We measure employee engagement as a composite score of five factors:

• Intent to stay – the likelihood that employees feel they will stay with the company in the next two years
• Work involvement – the psychological and emotional contribution employees develop and apply to their work
• Discretionary effort – the level of engagement efforts above the minimum required that people are willing to put into their work
• Pride in the company – the extent to which people feel proud to work there, and employees feel valued
• Willingness to recommend the organisation – how likely people are to recommend their organisation to friends and family

Each of these items provides a score which, when combined, gives an overall metric of employee engagement.

Tell the story with the data

Nobody feels excited and motivated by a mass of numbers and statistics on a screen. But combine your data with a strong, captivating visual story, and you can engage your audience, sparking enthusiasm and action. When you attach a story to your data, you can make an emotional impact on whoever sees it:

When you make visual storytelling that delivers a real emotional punch to the outcome of your data, there are three things that you need to do to set it up:

1. Start with the right questions: What does the data tell us? Who needs to see this data? How can we communicate that to the right audience?  How can we use that to make a difference?
2. Know your audience: How much do they know? How sophisticated are they? How familiar are they with the subject? All of this will help guide you in beginning to design your visual story.
3. Simplify, simplify, simplify: people want information delivered as quickly and simply as possible. Don’t try to do too much all at once. Edit your data and your information down to just give the crucial information needed to make your point. Then create your next visual to make your next point. Think of it as putting your story together one chapter at a time, instead of trying to do it all once.

Better storytelling will help your data insights make a greater impact. Download our ebook, and we’ll share best practices that will help you merge data and story in the most effective ways.

Analysing your results

Once your data is in, you need to turn it into insights.

With the right analysis, you can see what’s driving key metrics, such as engagement and retention, so you know where to focus your improvements and make engaged employees.

One of the latest tools here used in employee engagement research is EX25, which includes key driver analysis — a statistical test that surfaces the leading factors that have the biggest impact on employee experience.

It shows, in an easy-to-read format, the drivers of engagement, how important they are, and how people rated them.

The idea is that by focusing on the high impact/low scoring drivers, you’ll tackle areas with the biggest impact to engage employees in your company.

How to increase employee engagement

The best way to boost employee engagement is by taking action on the insights. Here’s how to make sure your employee engagement insights result in meaningful change and improvements in employee satisfaction for your people.

There’s a science to improving levels of employee engagement. But unfortunately, there’s no simple cookie-cutter approach — it all comes down to understanding your key drivers and company context so you can take action to improve what will have the biggest impact.

There are two strategies you can use to approach your improvements – create changes at an organisational level and changes within individual teams.

In most cases, you’ll need to do both.

• At an organisational level, work with your leadership team to identify the key drivers that affect everyone.
• At a team level, this is where you’ll make the biggest impact. The vast majority of key drivers are things direct supervisors can impact, such as career growth, resolving issues at work, or clarifying objectives.

The old saying “people don’t leave companies; they leave managers” is oversimplified, but the underlying notion is spot on. Gallup reports that 50% of employees who quit a job cite their boss as the primary reason.

Maintaining employee engagement

An employee engagement program is not static — it will evolve over time as your workforce changes or as your employee engagement strategy matures. If you’ve been running your employee engagement program for a while, you may find it’s no longer getting the responses or results it used to. This may just mean that it needs a refresh. Here’s what you can do.

Review your questions

Look in detail at the questions you’re asking. Some of them may now be redundant or irrelevant and need to be removed.

Keep an eye out for questions that:

• score very highly year-over-year
• are frequently skipped (this could be because they’re either not relevant or the question is confusing)
• are not actionable or answerable – every item should have an action and resources connected to it
• now seem irrelevant or outdated to your organisation

Take a look at your reporting review

Assess the effectiveness and impact of your executive and team reporting so that it can be improved. Make sure that you:

• know who your audiences are for reporting, and so that you can reach each one
• have resources in place for your managers to facilitate necessary change
• consider other forms of reporting, such as videos and animations to communicate your results in an impactful way

Reconsider frequency

The timing of your engagement survey is critical to getting a good response rate. If you usually do an annual survey, also consider:

• The huge benefits of running employee surveys more than once a year (A lot changes in a year)
• Would shorter, more frequent employee surveys be better for the rhythm of your business?

Employees whose employer turns feedback into action “really well” are twice as engaged as those whose employer does not act on their feedback well, according to the our 2022 Global Trends Report.

Personalize engagement

Think about ways you can engage better with individual employees on the survey. You could have:

• individual reports for each employee to view a summary of their results upon completion
• a central place for employees to view results, or a general sharing of results
• other channels of communication – do you rely solely on email, are there other platforms you can use?

Refresh branding

Make your survey look up to-the-minute and relevant by freshening up the design with colours and features.

If you have a creative team, let them loose on designing a new brand and theme for your program. Do you have a strong name for the initiative?

Refresh the online branding and site coding where necessary. If you have internal resources that design your website in CSS, they can help design a theme for the your survey that feels consistent.

Using employee engagement software to find insights

Using an employee engagement platform is an effective and scalable way to automatically analyse the data.

The best engagement platforms make running complex analysis easy, whether it’s identifying the key drivers of engagement or automatically surfacing the actions that have the biggest impact on engagement.

The best platforms also map the results back to the organisational hierarchy, delivering them straight to managers’ inboxes so they can get stuck in immediately and start improving things for their teams.

Why use EX25 for your employee engagement surveys?

Our new EX25 solution is the next generation of employee engagement. It enables you to:

• Improve employee satisfaction and drive employee engagement across your whole business
• Pulse your employees at the right cadence, so you can stay in tune with employees throughout the year, while avoiding survey fatigue
• Access a comprehensive library of scientifically validated items, including 5 KPIs to track employee experience and 25 drivers, critical topics that impact KPIs
• Act rapidly on real-time data to address problems
• See how your actions impact employee workplace productivity and
  organisational KPIs
• Supply leaders with comprehensive data and action planning using dashboard templates with analysis of employee feedback to help understand and address the top drivers of employee engagement across their teams
• Reduce unwanted and costly attrition and improve employee retention
• Benchmark your own employee engagement results with global, industry, and
  Fortune 500 companies
• Receive expert-designed action guidance that helps leaders meaningfully improve on each experience driver.

With EX25, you’ll be able to empower every manager in your business to survey, improve and measure employee engagement with real-time insights. These insights show exactly where leaders can direct their efforts to increase employee performance – and experience.

This article was written by the EmployeeXM team

Our EX Scientists are a global team of Employee Experience consultants who deliver advisory services for our clients to help them design and deliver world class EX strategies & programs. They provide empirically driven, best practice solutions.